Skip to content
  • About
  • Services
    • Phone Interview
    • Initial Meeting
    • Invention Analysis
    • Plan of Action
    • Invention Design
    • 2D/3D Illustrations
    • Invention Engineering
    • Patent Protection
    • Market Research
    • Manufacturers Search
    • Invention Brochures
    • Licensing & Royalties
  • Submit
  • Benefits
  • Blog
  • Contact
Menu
  • About
  • Services
    • Phone Interview
    • Initial Meeting
    • Invention Analysis
    • Plan of Action
    • Invention Design
    • 2D/3D Illustrations
    • Invention Engineering
    • Patent Protection
    • Market Research
    • Manufacturers Search
    • Invention Brochures
    • Licensing & Royalties
  • Submit
  • Benefits
  • Blog
  • Contact

972-402-0000

Irving, Texas

  • About
  • Services
    • Phone Interview
    • Initial Meeting
    • Invention Analysis
    • Plan of Action
    • Invention Design
    • 2D/3D Illustrations
    • Invention Engineering
    • Patent Protection
    • Market Research
    • Manufacturers Search
    • Invention Brochures
    • Licensing & Royalties
  • Submit
  • Benefits
  • Blog
  • Contact
Menu
  • About
  • Services
    • Phone Interview
    • Initial Meeting
    • Invention Analysis
    • Plan of Action
    • Invention Design
    • 2D/3D Illustrations
    • Invention Engineering
    • Patent Protection
    • Market Research
    • Manufacturers Search
    • Invention Brochures
    • Licensing & Royalties
  • Submit
  • Benefits
  • Blog
  • Contact
Free Invention Analysis

Study Shows Finance Patents Lowest in Quality

  • December 15, 2015
Study Shows Finance Patents Lowest in Quality

Here’s a patent discovery that may or may not come as a surprise. A patent search to determine the quality of patents reveals that inventions from the financial services industry score the lowest on patent quality.

As part of the “Financial Patent Quality: Finance Patents After State Street” report conducted by Harvard Business School, researchers used standard measures of quality to compare finance patents and non-finance patents.

Sparking the research was the 1998 Federal Circuit’s State Street Bank & Trust Co., versus Signature Financial Group, Inc., decision, which permitted software programs or other processes that transform data to be patented. Prior Supreme Court decisions ruled that business methods inventions were not patentable.

According to the authors of the research, Josh Lerner, Mark Baker, Andrew Speen, and Ann Leamon, the study looked at 2,799 patents granted by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) after the 1998 decision through 2010.

The key indicators researchers used in defining patent quality were:

  • The number of academic prior art cited in the patent application.
  • The type of references cited, such as academic, non-academic, etc.
  • Patent strength in terms of its validity or defensibility.
  • Patent social value with regards to the innovativeness and technological significance of the invention.
  • Patent private value in terms of the financial gains the patent owner will realize from the patented rights to the invention.

The study found that financial services patents had fewer citations to demonstrate a prior art search. Prior art is used by patent examiners to determine whether the patent filing contains a new and useful idea. Insufficient prior art leaves a patent open to litigation.

“Although we found that examiners do add more non-patent prior art to finance patents than to the patents in our two comparison groups, finance patents still lagged in non-patent prior art citations and particularly in academic citations. The differences grew as we moved into more prestigious journals and for individual/NPE-assigned patents,” explains Lerner, a patent expert who led the research team and is head of the Entrepreneurial Management at Harvard Business School.

The researchers further found that:

  • Finance patents cite fewer non-patent prior art publications versus the comparison groups.
  • There is a strong relationship between a lack of citations of academic prior art and the likelihood of a patent being litigated.
  • Financial services patents granted to corporations typically cite more prior art than those granted to individuals or those associated with non-practicing entities (NPEs).
  • Business method patents are more likely to be litigated and more intensely than non-finance patents.

The patent search study is part of Askeladden LLC’s Patent Quality Initiative, an education, information, and advocacy effort established by The Clearing House banking association and payments company. The initiative is aimed at improving the understanding, use, and reliability of patents in financial services and other industries.

“It is critically important to address the shortcomings of patent quality in order to improve the understanding, reliability, and innovation of patents in financial services,” notes Sean Reilly, Askeladden General Counsel and head of the Patent Quality Initiative. “Askeladden commissioned this research to better understand the patent quality challenges in the financial services industry. This study reinforces the need for patent examiners to have access to the most pertinent prior art.”

Since the 1998 court decision, there has been a surge in the number of finance patents and litigation surrounding them.

The report’s findings demonstrate a need to address the type of inventions being patented in the financial services industry and the strength of their academic basis.

  • Intellectual Property, Inventions, Patents
Inventions
Tech

Latest Posts

This device tells you when the stove’s been left on
This device tells you when the stove’s been left on
Are you the type of person who needs to check that the stove is off five times before leaving the ...
WeMo is a smart plug that allows you to control appliances remotely
WeMo is a smart plug that allows you to control appliances remotely
Have you ever left the iron on, only to remember hours later while you're sitting at your desk at work? ...
The pocket-sized Nix Sensor digitizes colors on demand
The pocket-sized Nix Sensor digitizes colors on demand
Assuming that you're in fact not some sort of color wizard, The Nix Mini Color Sensor could be an awesome ...
Sit back, relax, and let this electric bike go 236 miles on one charge
Sit back, relax, and let this electric bike go 236 miles on one charge
E-bike technology isn't exactly new — we've seen multiple scattered across the Internet for a few years now, all claiming ...
Think you can invent a personal jetpack? Boeing could give you $2 million for it
Think you can invent a personal jetpack? Boeing could give you $2 million for it
Boeing really wants to make personal jetpacks a thing, and they’re asking for your help. Boeing is sponsoring the GoFly ...
Use this super smart case to instantly print photos from your phone
Use this super smart case to instantly print photos from your phone
The upside to advanced camera phone technology is super sharp pictures we can’t help but share on just about every ...
Previous
Next
View all Posts

What's on Your Mind?

Submit your Idea for your Free
Patent Search Now.

FREE PATENT SEARCH
  • 972.402.0000
  • [email protected]

What's on Your Mind?

Submit your Idea for your Free
Patent Search Now.

FREE PATENT SEARCH
  • 972.402.0000
  • [email protected]

Give Us a Call

972.402.0000

Evaluate

  • Phone Interview
  • Initial Meeting
  • Invention Analysis
  • Plan of Action

Develop

  • Invention Design
  • 2D/3D Illustrations
  • Invention Engineering
  • Patent Protection

Launch

  • Market Research
  • Manufacturers Search
  • Invention Brochures
  • Licensing & Royalties

Address

6565 N.MacArthur Blvd, Irving, Texas 75039

Phone

972.402.0000

800.962.3032

972.402.0095

Email

[email protected]

Evaluate

  • Phone Interview
  • Office Meeting
  • Invention Analysis
  • Plan of Action

Develop

  • Invention Design
  • 2D/3D Illustrations
  • Invention Engineering
  • Patent Protection

Launch

  • Market Research
  • Manufacturers Search
  • Invention Brochures
  • Licensing & Royalties

Follow Us

Facebook-f Instagram Linkedin-in Pinterest-p Twitter
© 2022, Lonestar Patent Services, Inc.

Privacy Policy | Terms of Use

Free Invention Analysis

×

Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA)

This agreement keeps your idea safe between you and Lonestar Patent Services.

I understand that the product idea information I submit cannot be used, disclosed or sold without my express written permission. I also understand that all Lonestar Patent Services employees are required to sign an ethics and confidentiality agreement for my protection. I believe that I am the original inventor of the idea described herein. I authorize Lonestar Patent Services to review my idea and contact me in 3 to 5 business days with the results. I acknowledge that Lonestar Patent Services monitors and records telephone calls for quality assurance. I understand that Lonestar Patent Services does not promise any financial gain from the development of any new product idea.

By clicking the “submit” button below as my electronic signature, I expressly consent to being contacted about Lonestar Patent Services by phone call, auto-dialed phone call including prerecorded voice messages, text messages or email at any number or email address I provide. I understand that my consent is not a requirement for purchase of services.

Fee based service.